Mar 19 2013

Treasure Detectives in CNBC



A Fake Baseball Card along with a Fake Tiffany Lamp

By Scott M. Haskins, Art Conservator


Almost far more interesting than the items they gather, art collector?s personalities and thoughts set seems to be the vibe that Hollywood is after. I guess that?s why, at the moment, it seems Television is awash with wild characters who scour the countryside locating junk, restoring things, appraising and bidding on supposedly sealed storage units.


If had some private speak to together with the producers and production group at Treasure Detectives (CNBC Tues nights) and I find this show really fascinating. Its can be a extremely exciting show that offers with all the authenticity of collectibles.


Within the show that aired this week, there was certainly an excellent object lesson to become discovered from if you paid focus towards the psychology of the collectors, anything I hope it is possible to relate to. I cope with the thoughts set of collector?s all the time and, coincidentally, it turned out that on the very same morning as the Tv show, I had 3 paintings to evaluate for authenticity come into the lab? all of them before noon!


The 3 things that came in have been supposed to become by Matisse, Franz Bischoff and Maynard Dixon. Hopes had been speedily dashed, even so as the Matisse was swiftly identified as a print and also the two other oils had been far beneath the good quality from the supposed artists. The owners came into my workplace in hopes of getting, collectively, $1 million. I was surprised how lightly they took the undesirable news, nevertheless. They must not happen to be expecting a constructive response. In these three circumstances, all it took a fast appear as well as the fakes were identified so I didn?t charge them something. Nevertheless, see, beneath, how the bill can be run up?


How often do fakes show up at my door? When I’ve reason to start probing for authentication kind information, a minimum of 90% don?t pass the test.


Tues. March 12th?s episode of Treasure Detectives dealt with the value of a Tiffany lamp plus a potentially super useful baseball card.


Comparing blown up pictures from the baseball card in query plus a fake card they made around the show.


The two owners from the two things were in a completely various spot mentally.

1. The baseball card owner had inherited the card in 1980 and had, over the years revered it and produced up an extraordinary story and value in his thoughts. For him, the item was completely authentic and its potential value of $3 million was tied tightly to his ego.

two. The Tiffany lamp was bought a couple of years ago by a really seasoned antiques collector who states that he has the largest and most useful collection of Tiffany in the State of Kentucky.


In the case on the baseball card, it turned out that a number of particulars sunk that boat and it was declared 100% fake. The owner was devastated, of course, but produced worst by the truth that the owner took the news personally. The provenance, the reverence for such a rare item, the story the owner had in his thoughts all contributed to him not looking at this ?investment? in an objective way. By the way, it is my estimate that the authentication processes they went by way of on the show could have price the owner about $15,000.00 if he were paying for the work and investigation.


The Tiffany lamp turned out to become a 1950s reproduction and was fraudulently sold as a Tiffany. In other words, the objective was to deceive. The owner was disappointed naturally however it was exciting to me that an seasoned antiques buyer and one particular so familiar with Tiffany would get some thing Before getting it checked out. I?m confident he shrugged off the $5,000.00 purchase price tag of his bogus lamp and moved on to other hunting grounds. It truly is my estimate that the authentication method they went through on the show could have expense the owner about $10,000.00 of he were paying for the operate and research.


Here are a few recommendations that may be learned from this episode of Treasure Detectives:

1. Have your item checked out by professionals prior to a buy or caveat emptor and endure the consequences.

two. Provenance or the documented history of the item is as easy to make up as a good story. Fake provenances are a lot more widespread than excellent ones. If the documentation is produced up of physical papers etc and they all appear great? be far more wary, the a lot more expensive the item is becoming sold for.

three. Think about that all knowledgeable dealers and collectors purchase fake stuff. Don?t take it personally? but don?t get taken also typically! #1 on this list will maintain this from taking place to you. Certainly one of my dealer-clients hasn?t purchased a painting in 30 years with a fake signature because I take a look at every and every acquire for him Prior to buying if he has the minimal question.


In the system?s own words: “Treasure Detectives requires you deep inside the globe of arts, antiques and collectibles. Curtis Dowling and his group of investigators confirm the authenticity of collectibles, artwork and antiquities making use of revolutionary technology and street smarts. Is it a fake or is it worth a fortune??



Among the standard techniques for inspecting artwork prior to purchase is with a robust UV blacklight. See this article and video for a lot more info: This isn’t a slam-dunk-easy-to-read technique for seeing previous restorations and also other essential specifics. It needs plenty of practice on lots of diverse sorts of products. But its entertaining!




For any news post featuring Scott M. Haskins?s, Click here:


For art conservation, painting restoration and art authentication  inquiries get in touch with Scott M. Haskins 805 564 3438 or


For art appraisal concerns get in touch with Richard Holgate at 805 895 5121 or


See short videos by Scott M. Haskins on art conservation connected subjects at YouTube channel ?Bestartdoc?


To discover far more about what it is possible to do at house to care for your stuff, download now a copy of Scott’s book, The best way to Save Your Stuff From A Disaster at 50% off!

CLICK Here to know more:


See short do-it-yourself videos on collection care and emergency preparedness for art collectors, household history products, heirlooms, memorabilia at Youtube Channel ?preservationcoach?


Stick to us on Facebook

Ideas for Art Collectors

Fine Art Conservation

Save Your Stuff

Scott M. Haskins


On, sign up within the side column with your e-mail address so you can be updated whenever I post a new write-up or video for art collectors!